Making Another Bootleg Baby With Liveherenow Recordings?

[BeautifulBurnout]

Originally Posted by galama

After healthy sales would anyone, especially LHN, really care if some hardcore fans compile a CD? I don't think so. Would anyone get persecuted? Probably not, but definitely YES if someone is actually trying to make money.
And finally, with all the piracy made possible by the beautiful internet, we are huring no one, hurting no one.
We can come up with lots of pros and cons and never make a move. It's interesting where this is going to. Methinks it all comes down to consensus.

<rant>
Would anyone, especially Underworld, get pissed off at reading this, after all the free goodies, the live streamings, the radio shows they give us hardcore fans year in year out? Damn!

Whether you are trying to make money from it or not is irrelevant. What you are doing by suggesting sharing this kind of thing is preventing THEM from making money from one of their own products. Irrespective of the legality or the likelihood of being sued, it is morally wrong to do that, especially on here, and especially if you are a fan.

Methinks it all comes down to some people wanting something for nothing - again. And Karl was right to have his little dig about that during the Southampton radio broadcast too, because no matter how much they give us, there always seems to be someone who wants more for free, rather than sticking their hand in their pocket.

Show some respect, ffs. Do whatever you want to do privately, but don't promote stealing music from our favourite band on their official fan forum. Ta.

</rant>

Edit: On the point of BB1 being illegal or otherwise, my understanding is that permission was sought and given for that project. It most certainly would not be for something like this, for all the reasons stated