Elton John or Billy Joel

[myshkin]

On a desert island with a piano, and one of these two legends. You can't have both of them. And no, George Michael doesn't do guest appearances.

[jOHN rODRIGUEZ]

After a while either one would become pretty fucking annoying.

Then again, I'd be annoying too. Just spare us all the trouble and let the sharks get us.

[BeautifulBurnout]

Oh my god what a question.

Early Elton... I'm thinking "Goodbye Yellow Brick Road" era.... passable.

Uptown Girl by Billy Joel... no WAY!

Gotta be Elt.

If I have to choose.

You are MAKING me choose, right?

[BrotherLovesDub]

easy. elton john.

[koisk]

I can't believe I'm hearing this. Billy > Elton. Go on and try to debate it. Your attempts are futile.

[ndrwrld]

if youre gay = elton.
if youre me = billy joel.

[jOHN rODRIGUEZ]

Sexuality really doesn't come into play with either. They're music men.

AND I'm not offended or anything by your comment. It's just I myself shift more toward Joel's songs than John's. Not to mention all of the song's I like by John are the depressing one's and WTF I'm gay in every definition of the term. Annoyingly Bubbles kinda gay when I'm not pissy.

[patrick]

i would honestly do my best to kill myself as fast as i can... honestly...

complete crap

[myshkin]

Though if you found the decision too difficult, you could try lighting a fire, using your SAS skills of course, and burning the piano. And then simply engage in interesting chats with either of these two heroes. Though you would be foregoing the pleasures of ever hearing Candle in the Wind or Uptown Girl in uniquely intimate one to one performances.

[big screen satellite]

you know there is an add a poll option to these threads....

just saves me reading every ones responses...

but well left alone on a Desert Island...mmm

probably EJ for the Moosik which i prefer... thats just my vote (but as long as he doesn't play Nikkita or that bloody Princess Di Track)