Barking: The Alternate Versions (Disc 2)

[Vancouver]

Originally Posted by TheBang

You Do Scribble (Abbey Road Version) is different from You Do Scribble on CD2.

Excellent. Thanks for the info.

[testudo]

junkies, criminals, fugitives...

[TheBang]

drums drums drums (and guns and rock)

[potatobroth]

YDS is great to have in these two forms. Oddly enough, the catchiness of Scribble does get stuck in my head and i end up singing it even though I don't really like it.

Both YDS and YDS (Abbey Road) are FANTASTIC. Great additions to this release.

Strumpet is okay. Kinda miss the "gets much better" piece from the electraglide show so many years back.

All in all, its like a fantastic release of Bsides. Love it.

[potatobroth]

OK, I know we don't want to do this, but I'm gonna have to agree with whoever said Grace (Telematic Peal Mix) is the better version. It's pretty great. The album version is great too, but something more Underworld about the alt.

[Dino3D]

I listened to the samples of the alternate takes, and I glad that the differences between the demos and the final produced versions are minimal. The biggest differences are Scribble and ALAF, but the final versions are better, luckily.
So if the differences so minimal, I don't know why needed the producers.

[purlieu]

Strumpet Groove and Bird 1 are pretty different.

[crank]

LOVE Hamburg Hotel Essex. So much better.

[Cadevil]

Got my box set yesterday...it's something pretty, and I love all of the notes on each song. The note to the fans at the start is cool. This thing was clearly made for the fans on Dirty.

Whoever said this was an "insult to the fans" is an idiot.

[crank]

I just love the fact that the songs on the DVD are different even from disc 2. So it's like we have 3 different versions of the trax. ROCK on.