toronto oct 2002 gig - Page 2

the real stuff · #11 07-24-2006, 06:56 AM

awesome. something to look forward to.

ndrwrld · #12 07-24-2006, 03:50 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by stimpee

I have this in FLAC. I plan to release it as is via RTSR, which is where all live trading conversations should be taking place.

ummm...i never said id ' release ' this anywhere, anyhow ' , to anyone here, nor anywhere.
and if i decide to share this with anyone, it wont be completely public on here, because id hate to get your girdle in a knot.
oceanic...message me on soulseek sometime...we need to talk.

BeautifulBurnout · #13 07-24-2006, 03:53 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ndrwrld

ummm...i never said id ' release ' this anywhere, anyhow ' , to anyone here, nor anywhere.
and if i decide to share this with anyone, it wont be completely public on here, because id hate to get your girdle in a knot.

No. You were just bragging, you swine!

ndrwrld · #14 07-24-2006, 04:58 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by BeautifulBurnout

No. You were just bragging, you swine!

maybe a bit.

BeautifulBurnout · #15 07-24-2006, 05:07 PM

After the shit you and Samrahl have just been through you deserve something nice

Gimme Gimme Gimme!

</muttley>

stimpee · #16 07-24-2006, 05:15 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ndrwrld

ummm...i never said id ' release ' this anywhere, anyhow ' , to anyone here, nor anywhere.
and if i decide to share this with anyone, it wont be completely public on here, because id hate to get your girdle in a knot.
oceanic...message me on soulseek sometime...we need to talk.

no you didnt. but bragging has the same effect. however, it has forced me into working on it and i'll release it on RTSR asap. Then your mates at Tribe can get their copies too

stargurl · #17 07-24-2006, 11:36 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ndrwrld

ummm...i never said id ' release ' this anywhere, anyhow ' , to anyone here, nor anywhere.
and if i decide to share this with anyone, it wont be completely public on here, because id hate to get your girdle in a knot.

And yet you posted about having this file on another forum, then arranged for it to be freely shared online after somebody offered to host it. Why act like you have something super-rare that you're not going to share on one forum, then publicly brag about it on another?

oceanic · #18 07-25-2006, 12:21 AM

Yikes. I won't even ask for it, ndr. You might get a spanking.

BeautifulBurnout · #19 07-25-2006, 01:20 AM

Dear oh deary me.

If he has been given permission to share it, (and no prizes for guessing where that permission has come from) what's the issue here exactly? If RTSR people have had this and been sitting on it for whatever reason, surely ndrwrld is right to offer this to the larger community? Many people have never heard this gig in its entirety and, while they would prefer to have a good quality copy of it, if there is any copy available at all, I am sure they would want to hear it. Or is it about who controls the releases, because that is what this is beginning to sound like.

I don't remember any clause in the RTSR code of conduct that bans members from sharing things with other people for free, or obtaining copies of gigs not yet available from other people, members or not.

stargurl · #20 07-25-2006, 01:53 AM

I have no problem with the sharing of the file, especially if permission's been given. I was there, it was a great show, and I'm happy that a bootleg exists.

I just find it kind of unfair for someone to say here that something hasn't been released, and that a decision hasn't been made about sharing it, when they've already posted it somewhere else.

Who knows, maybe the download link posted on the other forum was sent by PM to people on here - that would seem the fair thing to do, wouldn't it?