CD vs. Vinyl

[verbal]

For this poll, lets assume you own a CD player AND a turntable, and are able to record from your turntable.

If an album you are going to buy is available on CD and vinyl, which would you buy and why?

[myrrh]

(this entire post is assuming you are recording into your computer)

I think that you are over simplifying this.

Recording your new records take time. Much more time than putting your new CD onto your computer, because you have to actually sit there and listen to the record while it is recording.

Then there is the actual sound of record, which is different than the sound of a CD.

Then there is the fact that vinyl noise gets recorded along with the song you are recording.

Those kind of things you don't have to worry about with a CD.

So, if you are buying the music simply for the pure audio enjoyment of listening to the delicious sounds of the music, and you have an solid system to listen to it on, and the music was easily available in both CD and vinyl, I would chose vinyl, because vinyl sounds better.

But, if you are buying the music to rip onto your MP3 player, or computer, or to listen to in your car, then I would chose a CD, because it is much quicker and more convienent to do these things with a CD.

[dubman]

call it stubborn, but when i first started getting music, it wasn't on vinyl.
since then, i never saw a significant reason to go to vinyl, and so i own lots and lots and lots of CDs.

[gambit]

A CD for easier storage.

[BeautifulBurnout]

Myrrh has pretty much summed it up for me.

[undarrenworld]

Originally Posted by myrrh

So, if you are buying the music simply for the pure audio enjoyment of listening to the delicious sounds of the music, and you have an solid system to listen to it on, and the music was easily available in both CD and vinyl, I would chose vinyl, because vinyl sounds better.

Yeah, thats it no need to add more...

[undarrenworld]

Originally Posted by myrrh

So, if you are buying the music simply for the pure audio enjoyment of listening to the delicious sounds of the music, and you have an solid system to listen to it on, and the music was easily available in both CD and vinyl, I would chose vinyl, because vinyl sounds better.

Yeah, thats it no need to add more...

[undarrenworld]

Originally Posted by myrrh

So, if you are buying the music simply for the pure audio enjoyment of listening to the delicious sounds of the music, and you have an solid system to listen to it on, and the music was easily available in both CD and vinyl, I would chose vinyl, because vinyl sounds better.

Yeah, thats it no need to add more...

[verbal]

I'm not really over simplifying it. You're on the right track though.

I'm saying regardless of time, regardless of any other factor than you plan on listening to it on your computer and putting it on an MP3 player.

Even if you don't factor in the above-- choose whichever medium you would purchase just for listening alone if both were available.

Factoring in time of recording, converting, and all that is over complicating it.

[justy]

I'm kinda on the fence with this one. There have been cases where I prefer recording from vinyl to ripping from CD, like the Beatles' White Album, where the CD sounds like crap, so recording from vinyl was a definite improvement in sound quality. Many mid-80/early 90s CDs have pretty bad sound quality. Compare, for instance, My Bloody Valentine's Loveless on CD to the vinyl. There's a good bit more detail on the vinyl release.

For most modern releases, I prefer CD for ease, and maybe I'll buy the vinyl too if I really like it. For older releases, I'll prefer a good remastered CD over a first-release CD (compare many Sony/Columbia Records Jazz releases to special remastered versions of the same releases), but if there isn't a remastered version, I'll prefer vinyl.