[myshkin]

Originally Posted by TheRev

If you were talking strictly about the Studio version of Ummagumma alone I'd agree with you about its rating below Piper. There's some SERIOUS noodling up in that piece. HOWEVER, throw in the live version and we're playing a different game. The Live version however is quite cohesive and is utterly sublime.

.....set your controls for the heart of the sun........

I certaiinly wouldn't argue against Set the Controls and its extended prehistoric spaceman workout by Rick Wright.