Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Dirty0900
I do think a lot of the things on the RRP sound very flat compared to live stuff.
|
Well I guess I'm looking at it like this:
Lenny Penne is pretty similar in both live shows and its RRP counterpart. The
Lovely Broken Thing version is a complete track and I think, a pretty well done one at that. In concert its pretty similar (with the addition of
You Do Scribble, becomes something else.) The
Cups outro holds up well on both the album and in live shows but only as an outro. It works well bleeding off of another song but never quite becomes its own track. At least not a track that I will fast-forward to listen to. At the end of another track however, its great.
That was how I was all set to think about
Back in the Fears, as the new outro to
Food a Ready. Then I heard the Electraglide show and was quite simply blown away by its transformation from outro to full on track. I instantly went back to listen to RRP and was a little saddened to hear that the produced version lacked any of the power of the live one. I don't mean to say that it doesn't have a nice sound to it, but is just 'flat' as you say Dirty0900 in comparisson to itself.
Cups outro remains as powerful live and produced.
Lenny Penne the same.
Back in the Fears, however is a different story.