View Single Post
  #135  
Old 12-28-2011, 04:03 PM
negative1
-1
 
Join Date: Jul 2005
Location: east coast usa
Posts: 2,482
Re: discography classification
Quote:
Originally Posted by Mike View Post
Great work Raj, im so pleased this is up to date again I find it a really useful source of data.

I have a couple of things to ask / challenge:

Just for clarity, im not sure why we don't include Dark & Long Christian Smith mixes? It seems to be a legitimate release, and Underworld are credited as the artist. I would also argue that Cowgirl remixes by Bedrock and Futureshock are DJ mixes.
no problem, yeah, every few years is a good chance for more
things to be corrected, and added.. you never know what will
turn up... with the promo albums, and new 2011 edits.. i never
thought i would have to add to uw mk2 listing..

anyways.. i guess i'm trying to keep the releases
that underworld has put out.. [not that discogs is final]
such as cowgirl
----------------------
http://www.discogs.com/Underworld-Cowgirl/master/47411

compared to those put out by djs on compilations, or their
own name:
-----------------
http://www.discogs.com/Underworld-Da...elease/3095521

and under a non-underworld label..


Quote:
Also, do you think it would be better to separate Soundtracks? I consider the names of the tracks to be more of an Identification for the chapters of the films / productions rather than a release name as such... Also, Breaking and Entering is an Underworld & Gabriel Yarad collaboration, yet I assume that is the reason Downpipe & Beebop Hurry are missing from the list.
yeah, it gets messy with the soundtrack tracks,
and who worked with whom.. it's a tricky thing
to break out the collobarations. although underworld
played a major part on them..

frankenstein should stay - definitely underworld
the rest - sunshine, breaking and entering - iffy...

Quote:
The majority of "Barking" are collabs.

Mike
agreed, but it was put out under the name
of 'underworld' .. no puns intended..(a lot
of them in this post)...

i'm still trying to figure out how to make
a list of all the real collaborations... like
quazar, etc..

later
-1