Dirty Forums

Dirty Forums (https://www.borndirty.org/forums/index.php)
-   headset. (https://www.borndirty.org/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=8)
-   -   Party album of the CENTURY (https://www.borndirty.org/forums/showthread.php?t=3744)

Animal Boything 06-09-2006 09:19 PM

Party album of the CENTURY
 
I don't post here a lot anymore, but this is fucking important.

Girl Talk - Night Ripper

8-minute excerpt (my brother's bandwidth, be gentle)

link to more sample tracks, press release and ordering information

Sample tracks don't really do it justice, it's basically one 40-minute song.

This record has seriously blown the minds of everyone I know who has heard it, but since his extreme usage of samples forces him to remain underground, you are not exactly going to see Girl Talk on Mtv. Buy this album. Tell others to buy this album. This guy deserves to go platinum. I just put in an order for 15 copies because so many of my friends want one.

King of Snake 06-11-2006 02:05 AM

Re: Party album of the CENTURY
 
not really my idea of party music but whatever ;)

stimpee 06-11-2006 03:22 AM

Re: Party album of the CENTURY
 
Nah, thats not the party album of the century ;) surely it has to be this one. Its worth it just for the cover! :D

froopy seal 06-11-2006 03:49 AM

Re: Party album of the CENTURY
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Bez's Madchester Anthems
Disc 1
16. Only Rhyme That Bites - MC Tunes & 808 State

Wtf? I don't know that song (consciously) but could anybody please confirm it's weird?

mark3 06-11-2006 05:19 AM

Re: Party album of the CENTURY
 
Everyone's got their own taste...I couldn't stand more than 30 seconds :D

holden 06-11-2006 09:56 AM

Re: Party album of the CENTURY
 
i could never really understand the idea of a "party album"...does it mean the artist intends it to be a fun collection of songs that you listen to straight through at a party? Or that every cut is dance-worthy or a good time single that you can't go wrong playing at your next bash?

Anyway, i can;t really see people doing this at a party anyway.

Two so-called party albums i can think of: Ringo Starr's "I Wanna Be Santa" Christmas album ( i don't own this, thankfully, but when i came out, the press was saying "party album of the year!". Riiiight). Beck's "Midnite Vultures" ( a heck of a record, yes, but probably best taken in bits).

Personally, when i'm at a party, i like a little variety from the tunes. nothing annoys me more than when whomever is "Deejaying" leaves on a record or CD by one artist because the songs are mixed together. Booo! Shows no effort!;)

King of Snake 06-11-2006 02:19 PM

Re: Party album of the CENTURY
 
personally if I'd have to go trough my cd's for an "ultimate" party album I would probably put on something like Stanton Warriors - the Stantion Session or maybe the best of De-Phazz if it's gonna be a bit more downtempo.

Animal Boything 06-11-2006 02:32 PM

Re: Party album of the CENTURY
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by holden
i could never really understand the idea of a "party album"...does it mean the artist intends it to be a fun collection of songs that you listen to straight through at a party? Or that every cut is dance-worthy or a good time single that you can't go wrong playing at your next bash?

Anyway, i can;t really see people doing this at a party anyway.

Two so-called party albums i can think of: Ringo Starr's "I Wanna Be Santa" Christmas album ( i don't own this, thankfully, but when i came out, the press was saying "party album of the year!". Riiiight). Beck's "Midnite Vultures" ( a heck of a record, yes, but probably best taken in bits).

Personally, when i'm at a party, i like a little variety from the tunes. nothing annoys me more than when whomever is "Deejaying" leaves on a record or CD by one artist because the songs are mixed together. Booo! Shows no effort!;)

What on earth are you talking about? Did you click any of those links? Because it really sounds like you did not.

Also, I hate all of you, so far. I really do.

Leon 06-11-2006 03:14 PM

Re: Party album of the CENTURY
 
Avalanches.

party music.

patrick 06-11-2006 03:18 PM

Re: Party album of the CENTURY
 
2 live crew...



at least the parties i like



but actually, ac/dc is the party music i grew up with and love. nothing can get me going like hells bells!

jOHN rODRIGUEZ 06-11-2006 03:38 PM

Re: Party album of the CENTURY
 
and Back in Black and Dirty Deeds (no pun intnd) and, and, and

yeah I love AC/DC too.

dubman 06-11-2006 04:54 PM

Re: Party album of the CENTURY
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by holden
i could never really understand the idea of a "party album".

OBVIOUSLY.

this is.
so fucking crazy
and pretty damn amazing. straight shot hedonism, no smarts, just flat out destruction. yeah, it can be party, but it will both confuse and exhaust.
which is of course fantastic.

i love this and i want to buy it and i am broke until further notice. thanks :mad:

Tyler 06-11-2006 05:16 PM

Re: Party album of the CENTURY
 
This shit is terrible. Hipster bullshit to the fullest effect. I swear there is a template for this shit by now. People in cool haircuts and ironic tees be getting down. Ick. "We have such a stick up our art-school asses that the only way we can engage with pop culture is through a slick layer of irony" double ick.

crank 06-11-2006 05:37 PM

Re: Party album of the CENTURY
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Animal Boything
What on earth are you talking about? Did you click any of those links? Because it really sounds like you did not.

Also, I hate all of you, so far. I really do.

Hahahahahaahaaa,
I'm not laughing at you, I'm laughing WITH you. And surely you've been coming to the dirty boards long enough to know you'll get some sort of critique for a suggestion?

FYI: I don't talk about Stryper anymo(er...)

ze crank!

dubman 06-11-2006 05:37 PM

Re: Party album of the CENTURY
 
um...

i have plenty of friends who'd enjoy this who arent hopeless hipsters. barely so, even. they like stuff like this because it's pretty fun. and this one happens to be frenetic enough to warrant the strange alt-rock hiccup or two scattered througout . it ain't clever, but it doesnt stop moving, and does so quick enough to to keep itself excited.

then again i have a hard time spotting irony in music. i usually figure if people do stuff like this they at least like, if not love it enough to work on it as much as they do. if it were trully terrible it'd use its "too cool for thou" irony to purposely fuck up or do something awkward. this is too wrapped up in remaining nuts to be just fucking around.

dubman 06-11-2006 06:48 PM

Re: Party album of the CENTURY
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Animal Boything

the sample tracks are terrible. it's like i'm listening to two different albums.

did you just cop the best nine minutes or is this whole thing up to snuff?

kid cue 06-11-2006 09:08 PM

Re: Party album of the CENTURY
 
Very, very hipster. Tyler is right. ;)

One would argue that it's nonetheless fun music--but I'd counter that something about the way these songs are put together actually makes the sum add up to less than each of its individual parts! There's nothing wrong with enjoying a single well-built party song for everything that it is, and still more--actually, it can take a darned open mind.

adam 06-11-2006 09:32 PM

Re: Party album of the CENTURY
 
Changes too often more my taste.

holden 06-12-2006 12:41 PM

Re: Party album of the CENTURY
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Animal Boything
What on earth are you talking about? Did you click any of those links? Because it really sounds like you did not.

Exactly what i wrote. What exactly makes something a party album? An album that you'd play straight through? A compilation disc? A dj mix? Depends on what kinda party you're throwing and for whom. But the two silly examples i gave are both LPs that were advertised as "party albums", which makes me question who really plays them from start to finish without their guests getting fed up.
Maybe this is (i can't really dig it, thanks for the links, though), but it's clearly not for everyone. Calling something the whatever album of the CENTURY is bound for some backlash anyway, imho...better let the music defend, and this does not.

Leon 06-12-2006 01:38 PM

Re: Party album of the CENTURY
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by holden
Exactly what i wrote. What exactly makes something a party album? An album that you'd play straight through? A compilation disc? A dj mix? Depends on what kinda party you're throwing and for whom. But the two silly examples i gave are both LPs that were advertised as "party albums", which makes me question who really plays them from start to finish without their guests getting fed up.
Maybe this is (i can't really dig it, thanks for the links, though), but it's clearly not for everyone. Calling something the whatever album of the CENTURY is bound for some backlash anyway, imho...better let the music defend, and this does not.


Well, he's all excited, so he calls it the album of the century. Don't take it too seriously. If you can whine about this, you can whine about almost everything ;)

sanakan 06-12-2006 02:02 PM

Re: Party album of the CENTURY
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by holden
Calling something the whatever album of the CENTURY is bound for some backlash anyway, imho...better let the music defend, and this does not.

but most of all: don't call it only 6 years after the century started...!

dubman 06-12-2006 02:13 PM

Re: Party album of the CENTURY
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by holden
Exactly what i wrote. What exactly makes something a party album? An album that you'd play straight through? A compilation disc? A dj mix?

if you don't know it when you hear it, then what's the point in saying? it's like asking mr. kirby from 'all that heaven allows' how to lead a satisfying life.

and anyway it's called 'hype' you eunuchs. it's an invaluable and inseprable aspect of music.

i'd rather read that, being suitable to what is being plugged, rather than "i say, this is quite a cracker"

Tyler 06-12-2006 02:44 PM

Re: Party album of the CENTURY
 
Yeah, lay off A.B. for hyping it up. I much prefer wild enthusiasm to world-weary measured cynicism, and you should too. Too bad he's enthusiastic about a pretty crappy album, but hey you can't win em all.

Animal Boything 06-13-2006 12:30 AM

Re: Party album of the CENTURY
 
dubman: As I said before, the sample tracks don't really do it justice. Clipping parts from the middle removes the context, and this album is pure context.

My brother interviewed this guy once (which is as far as my connection to him goes). I decided to post the interview here because he actually addresses Tyler's points very directly, and it also goes a long way to sort of explain what's going on, because this is awfully strange music.

This will be posted in two parts, because it's long. I'd link it, but it's not online.

Quote:

Ice Skating in Heaven: A Few Words with Girl Talk

It’s a shame that the term “dream pop” is reserved for a dreary mode of indie rock characterized by whispery vocals and ethereal guitar textures. My dreams aren’t like that. My dreams are jumbled, absurdist collages of my psyche; if a pop song were to sound like a dream, it would have to sound like a hallucinating brain coughing up subconscious waste. Unless the stuff called “dream pop” is just supposed to put us to sleep, it’s an irritating misnomer. Mankind could do so much more with that name; shouldn’t there be pop music that accurately suggests the surrealism and inverted logic of dreams?
My dreams sound like Girl Talk. Born Gregg Gillis, Philly resident Girl Talk crafts electronic tracks that sound like the malfunctioning subconscious minds of the deeply pop-obsessed. Imagine Rick Dees having a delirious fever-dream after a stressful Weekly Top 40 taping, or Carson Daly on his deathbed with years of Total Request Live flashing before his eyes. A three-minute Girl Talk track pours out enough pop samples to fill up a full hour of pop radio, all maniacally squashed together into a perfectly-aligned menagerie of sound. To describe a Girl Talk song in writing would be close to impossible; even to catalogue all the samples used in any one track would be daunting. Recognizing fifty percent of the snippets of sound which get mashed up in the average Girl Talk joint would qualify one as a true pop expert.
For example, a recent internet release called “Pure Magic” (due to appear later this year on a 7” single released by 333 Recordings) is a frenetic hurricane of recent pop-rap tracks. Within the first minute, I can recognize tiny glimpses of hits by Kanye West, Lil’ Scrappy, Cam’ron, Digital Underground, Jay-Z, Juvenile, Petey Pablo and Clipse. These are only the bits I can recognize, mind you; plenty more half-second samples of pop songs slip by me, familiar, but too brief and obscured to place. It’s like a lightning round of Name That Tune in which we’re expected to pick out songs based on a single word (Jay-Z shouting “Hov’!” or Baby yelling “ey!”) or a fraction of a riff (a few notes of the liquid bassline from “The Humpty Dance”). While few among us could catch every reference and name every song, anyone who keeps up with pop music will find every second of it eerily familiar.
The breath of material he plunders is immense; guitar solos from Manfred Mann’s Earth Band nestle alongside Lil’ Jon lyrics and Coldplay piano melodies. Girl Talk’s biography on his website contains a list of his favorite artists, which range from The Lovin’ Spoonful to 2 Live Crew. How did this madman come to cultivate such a broad taste?
“I think I’m a pretty normal guy when it comes to listening to music,” Gillis tells me. “Most people enjoy a wide range of music; it’s typically only the underground types that confine themselves to strict genres and styles. I think the diverse sampling in my music gears it to a more general crowd. I’d hope that people who don’t know anything about weird electronic music could be blasting my songs in their car Friday night on their way to a party. Once you get deep enough into any particular underground scene, you can’t like or make music far from that style without people saying you’re into it for ironic or kitsch or novelty reasons. Fuck that.”
Early on, Girl Talk has brought up the I-word. It’s easy to assume that there’s a large element of ironic detachment involved in his music, since the general view among hipsters is that it’s impossible to properly enjoy mainstream proletarian music without a layer of irony insulating them from the common man. Girl Talk seems to be hip to just about everything under the sun, but he insists upon operating without the safety net of irony.
“Just because I understand why people would be really into Venetian Snares doesn’t mean that my love for Hall and Oates is an ironic thing. People oftentimes assume that if you’re not into a sort of underground music, it’s because you’re unexposed to it or don’t get it. I ‘get it’ when it comes to the appeal for experimental electronics, but I just like Top 40 better. It's totally un-ironic. I seriously don’t listen to much current underground music. When I get in my car, I turn the radio to the light rock radio station or I throw in my Nirvana cassette or whatever. I listen to ninety percent pop music.”
Accordingly, all manner of pop songs come under his knife. One of the unique joys of his music is hearing two songs that have no business within a mile of each other momentarily colliding. A track on his second LP begins with the piano intro to Richard Marx’s dorky pop hit “Right Here Waiting” overlaid with the lyrics to Khia’s raunchy “My Neck, My Back”: “all you ladies pop your pussy like this / shake your body don’t stop don’t miss.” Another track finds the chorus of Superdrag’s indie hit “Sucked Out” slapped on top of the notorious stadium-rock riff of Bon Jovi’s “Livin’ On A Prayer.” The juxtapositions are often hilarious, mostly because the songs involved fit together like puzzle pieces, as if they were always meant to be combined. I asked Mr. Gillis if the primary concern of these combinations was humor value or perfect musical counterpoint:
“It’s always based primarily on what I think sounds the best together. There’s definitely a humorous aspect to some of the juxtapositions, but I’m not trying to make goofball music. It’s kind of like Mobb Deep rapping over Thomas Dolby or Diddy rapping over the Police. That initially has some novelty and comedy value but people get over it and just get into the song itself. I like that Bon Jovi riff and that Superdrag chorus, and when I put them together, I think it sounds great. It’s funny, but I hope people can get over that and just be into it on a musical level.”
The earnestness of Gregg Gillis’s love of pop music is disarming. While he samples samples and makes dance tracks out of dance tracks, he prefers not to consider the avant-garde levels on which he operates. “I try not to think about the mind-blowing-ness of my music. Usually when I’m in a deep mood, I’ll keep my mind off of it by watching ‘Son of Mask.’” While his bizarre combinations bridge the gaps between far-flung pop styles, he’s not attempting any grand statements about our culture. “I don't try to make any statements in my music. The placements of the samples are all chosen specifically for musical reasons only. I don’t want people to think, I want people to sweat and cum and ice skate in heaven.”

Animal Boything 06-13-2006 12:31 AM

Re: Party album of the CENTURY
 
part two comin' atcha

Quote:

One might recall that when the sampling techniques of hip hop exploded into the public consciousness in the nineties, there was an understandable backlash. Songs like P. Diddy’s aforementioned “I’ll Be Missing You,” which featured the instrumentation of The Police’s “I’ll Be Watching You” were upheld by legions of squares as empty pop gestures, devoid of creativity. Some felt that hip hop production was artistically bankrupt, and heavy sampling amounted to irreverently ripping off hit tunes for guaranteed cash. Girl Talk’s music takes sampling to its absurd extreme, but Gillis doesn’t consider his music irreverent.
“I’ve always considered my music a celebration of pop music, basically paying homage to my favorite songs. I am tearing apart songs bit by bit and putting them in weird new contexts though, so I can understand how some old people might think that’s disrespectful. It’s interesting to note that sampling backlash, though, because now there’s a heavy backlash in the indie electronic nerd scene against bootlegs, mash-ups, and pop remixes.”
This second wave of the sampling backlash comes in the wake of the immense press coverage of underground hip hop producer Danger Mouse’s Grey Album, an album-length mix of Jay-Z’s Black Album and The Beatles’ White Album. While the press latched onto the idea of a Beatles/Jay-Z mash-up as a novel concept, the electronic underground turned away in contempt: their game had become mainstream, and mainstream means played out.
“It’s really ridiculous to me,” says Gillis. “People just love to hate on anything gaining some popular momentum. They need to give it a rest; sampling pop to make new pop is going to exist forever.”
Despite the popular momentum and mainstream press coverage, Girl Talk and many other indie electronic artists are unable to even consider courting mainstream success with their music due to the expense and legal hassles of clearing hundreds of pop samples for re-use. Despite the time and talent Gillis puts into his work, it may remain in a legal grey area for the foreseeable future. In fact, “grey area” may be a little generous: if his releases catch the eyes of those he samples, Girl Talk may be in trouble. His solution is to fly under the radar.
“There are many people putting out illegal music on smaller independent labels right now, so I don’t think it’s really a legal threat at this level. I haven’t had any problems, personally, but I was on a compilation called “Ministry of Shit” (on Spasticated Records) that got in some trouble for the title and artwork of the album.” In case you were wondering, the album copped the title and logo from the Ministry of Sound series of electronic compilations, replacing the word “Sound.”
Will the music industry ever catch up? However illegal, Girl Talk’s music is undeniably compelling, and Gillis believes that his style could catch on in a big way: “As far as this style blowing up, I can definitely see it. Straightforward mash-ups really took off a couple years ago and were played on mainstream radio and in clubs all over Europe and in some places in the USA. I think that my attention deficit style is even more in line with what people want to hear. Everything is so crazy and rapid these days; they always cut off videos halfway through during Total Request Live, and they never play full songs at clubs. I guess the pace of some of my material is a little too extreme for dancing, but I think people could deal and step up their moves.”

- - -

Those who want to experience Girl Talk’s music need look no further than their monitor. Girl Talk operates a modest web site at www.girl-talk.net, which contains links to sites where his music can be purchased. He also has a profile on Myspace Music (http://www.myspace.com/girltalkmusic), where surfers can find free samples of his tracks and colorful concert photos. You’d be well advised to check these photos out: According to Gregg, “live shows usually involve me dressed up in some bright clothing and spazzing around and getting sweaty and getting all up in the audience. Occasionally, at more locally-based shows, I have a synchronized dance squad I work with.”
A final question: Has Girl Talk ever played Girl Talk, the teen-girl party game from which he takes his name? Has Girl Talk ever had to call a boy on the phone and sing him a song?
“There’s actually a few versions of the game. I think I own three of them. I’ve never really played them. I’ve worn the fake zits from one version though.”

Rog 06-13-2006 05:04 AM

Re: Party album of the CENTURY
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by froopy seal
Wtf? I don't know that song (consciously) but could anybody please confirm it's weird?

its got a sample of an old western (theme music to the film 'The Big Country') in it with a sort of rap vocals.................;)

*YAWN*

dubman 06-13-2006 07:24 PM

Re: Party album of the CENTURY
 
GOOD.

i have friends who are like this guy, who would be considered all hipstered out simply for their strange attitudes towards media consumption. it's like if there's a disconnect between how you look or think and what media you're into, then it's supposed to be ironic, a term which both confuses and angers them. one of them: she dresses up a little odd, as white as white can get, and is super aggro, but her love for mac-dre is VERY real. cheap photo-shops, drunken freestyling, knitting, and violent bay-area rap arent some escapist uber-indie ideal to her, it's what she loves, and she can't stand it when douches with zero imagination accuse her of not being serious about it.

and it sounds like this guy is coming somewhat from that. so as TACKY as it is, it's good to know that there's the same kind of LOVE put into it.

and that "dream-pop" bit was dead on :D

also, he seems to be on the same label as the bran flakes. big plus!

edit: just remembered that this connected brother of yours is dr. thorpe! nice to see him write seriously (and well) about music, although his SA column (and front page adventures, these days) continue to endlessly entertain (old newspaper brawl being pretty memorable).
does he actually think underworld is washed up? ;)

kid cue 06-14-2006 01:01 PM

Re: Party album of the CENTURY
 
I'm not certain the Girl Talk interview does away with one's ability to read irony into his music. Regardless of whether or not the intent of his music, or his own appreciation of his source material, is ironic--his execution arguably exemplifies ironic kitsch, haphazardly (or intuitively, if you prefer, and as he claims) setting up juxtapositions and combinations with an effect that might be characterized as "detached amusement". Comparisons with mash-up culture at large are potentially misleading, since Girl Talk's roving, more-or-less linear pastiche of references more closely resembles a hyperactive DJ mix which avoids commitment or focus, rather than the single, potent welding of two or three songs in a 'proper' mash-up (which suggests an exploration of the potential in combining entire, complete pieces of music together)--the techniques may be identical, but have honestly been around since hip-hop. Painting his music as the newest manifestation of a nascent subculture is a bit of a red herring.

The overall effect, to me, is one of distancing--Girl Talk's musical choices may sound good and be real to him--but if your music simply amounts to a rapid succession of references (mash-ups included--combining this riff with that chorus simply references both at once), and you're not personally involved in any of the musical contexts or dialogues attached to your referents, then you're simply an observer, a consumer, playing connect-the-dots from outside the pop-cultural arena. Nothing inherently wrong with that, but the article and Girl Talk's quotes seemed to me to be making much more of something that's rather simple in reality.

dubman 06-14-2006 04:10 PM

Re: Party album of the CENTURY
 
the proper mash-up, containing two or three peices of music, is a limited process that holds up its value mainly in what it's doing but is sonically a novelty and consumer-oriented style of creation (not that there's anything wrong with that last phrase). hearing a lust for life/will smith clash is kind of thrilling at first, but once will smith gets into his second wind we become painfully aware that the creator merely put two and two together in a brief flash of great association, but imagination soon gave way to technique in an endeavour where the initial idea doesn't have the gas to last longer than that first minute or so.
i think girl talk takes that initial experience and augments it, gives it depth, by not only being oriented towards a culturally aware audience but directly engaging with it by moving at speeds that render many of its parts indecipherable, sometimes refusing a focused or deliberate style, forcing a majority of listeners to constantly feel a familiarity with what they're hearing without being able to place it (but also reaching checkpoints that are easily identifiable). in a sense this one-ups even sampling, since we now have the benefit of relevantrecontextualization, having source material for which we were around to for and know being mangled in this way. i think girl talk explicitly transcends being clever and connecting things by how its discordant nature connects nothing at all, but to me seems like a coherent and enthusiastic work.

Animal Boything 06-14-2006 07:50 PM

Re: Party album of the CENTURY
 
Well-put... two things to add. First, the beauty of this "attention deficit style" is that while the typical mash-up gets old as soon as you figure out what's going on, Girl Talk barely gives you TIME to figure out what's going on. He comes up with these amazing juxtapositions, but he only lets them last long enough to get the point across, then he mercilessly switches it up on you. People sometimes complain that he doesn't play enough of each song, but he's not mr. DJ here to play records for you, he's making his own music. Artists like The Avalanches and DJ Shadow are doing pretty much the same thing, you just don't normally catch as many of the references. Using immediately recognizable samples that recall whole songs is just part of his game, and it brings me to my other point.

In time, like anything of this nature, you get over the novelty of it, but that's when you realize that as music taken on its own terms, this album WORKS. At first hearing Biggie over Elton John is funny, even a little jarring, but after a few listens you're just in the groove, and that's when the real genius of Girl Talk hits. This music is "crazy" in concept, but in execution, all it is is flawless. He actually manages to keep the beat pumping for 40 minutes doing this shit. I dare any DJ to attempt it.

Dubman: Thanks for reading Dave's stuff. He has been very successful lately... he has a book deal based on his ongoing "Fashion SWAT" articles co-written with the wonderful Zack Parsons, and one of his "Your Band Sucks" articles was selected for inclusion in a reputable journal of the year's best music writing, apparently beating out such luminaries as Simon Reynolds.
And no, he actually digs Underworld almost as much as I do, that was just some harmless ribbing.

Also: Where's Tom? I think he'd like this album too.
PAGING DETOUR TO THIS THREAD

kid cue 06-14-2006 11:18 PM

Re: Party album of the CENTURY
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by dubman
i think girl talk takes that initial experience and augments it, gives it depth, by not only being oriented towards a culturally aware audience but directly engaging with it by moving at speeds that render many of its parts indecipherable, sometimes refusing a focused or deliberate style, forcing a majority of listeners to constantly feel a familiarity with what they're hearing without being able to place it (but also reaching checkpoints that are easily identifiable). in a sense this one-ups even sampling, since we now have the benefit of relevantrecontextualization, having source material for which we were around to for and know being mangled in this way. i think girl talk explicitly transcends being clever and connecting things by how its discordant nature connects nothing at all, but to me seems like a coherent and enthusiastic work.

I don't know. A lot of this argument seems to operate under arbitrary presumptions: Girl Talk's speed isn't utterly indecipherable to me, only irritating; it's precisely because I am able to follow his manifold juxtapositions and am consistently confronted by yet another switch-up that I find his strategy deflating rather than profound. You may call it transcendent, on account of its being different; I just find it cowardly and unsuccessful in a relatively new way. ;)

I'm also not sure what you mean by a "relevant" recontextualization. It can't be assumed that everyone knows this source material, just as it can't be assumed that in "proper" sampling (I'm not sure there is actually a distinction to be made between this and Girl Talk's sampling) that the audience isn't expected to catch the references (Kanye West immediately springs to mind). Again, you may call the music's discordance profound, but I just call it ... weakly ironic and ironically weak, whether or not it claims to be un-ironic. :)

But honestly, if it feels enthusiastic to you, then by all means be enthused. I'll just note that your reading of his approach's significance is as subject to debate as the effectiveness of his music.

And Animal Boything (I like your name by the way), I'm not sure the "making his own music" card works, for all the reasons I outlined in my previous post. The Avalanches and DJ Shadow are enormously informed by a DJ sensibility, and their music does formally and conceptually hold much in common with the standard DJ set. Girl Talk's music especially can't be taken on its own terms, because its cleverness is based on dot-connecting. Sampling, no matter how creative (again, not creative enough in this case IMHO), will never suddenly become creating--and that's not the point. I would argue that the Avalanches' and Shadow's music utilizes the capabilities of computer-based sequencing and sampling much more extensively than Girl Talk. One analogy that comes to mind: the former two would twist the words in a given sentence into new catchphrases, while Girl Talk simply rearranges them and renders them gibberish. This may seem to contradict my above claim that Girl Talk is not indecipherable, but it's more the effect of being able to read the collection of words, which never congeal into a full sentence. Not to take the hackneyed concept too seriously, but there's quite literally no "statement" being made here.

Still--it's perfectly fine to appreciate the consistency of his execution, but I tend to think of that as a perfection of an exercise, or a craft, rather than a creation of something new (sampling or not), i.e. a full art. I guess I'm just picturing a certain line that he definitely does not cross, precisely because he takes this one approach so far (to little consequence, IMO).

As a good friend of mine put it, "T.I. is the party album of the year". :D

dubman 06-15-2006 08:09 AM

Re: Party album of the CENTURY
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by kid cue
I don't know. A lot of this argument seems to operate under arbitrary presumptions: Girl Talk's speed isn't utterly indecipherable to me, only irritating; it's precisely because I am able to follow his manifold juxtapositions and am consistently confronted by yet another switch-up that I find his strategy deflating rather than profound. You may call it transcendent, on account of its being different; I just find it cowardly and unsuccessful in a relatively new way. ;)

either i dont follow or this is a matter of opinion

Quote:

I'm also not sure what you mean by a "relevant" recontextualization. It can't be assumed that everyone knows this source material, just as it can't be assumed that in "proper" sampling (I'm not sure there is actually a distinction to be made between this and Girl Talk's sampling) that the audience isn't expected to catch the references (Kanye West immediately springs to mind). Again, you may call the music's discordance profound, but I just call it ... weakly ironic and ironically weak, whether or not it claims to be un-ironic. :)
7/10 whatever is sampled in a song is either completly obscure to the point that people get excited about what they do recognize. this throws everything you do know at you, and, to me, at a speed where you're constanly going "i know that" but then it's gone. i find it pretty engaging, but apparently there's different ways of hearing it. and again, i completly do not understand how something can be ironic without it intending to be.

Quote:

But honestly, if it feels enthusiastic to you, then by all means be enthused. I'll just note that your reading of his approach's significance is as subject to debate as the effectiveness of his music.
oh absolutely ;). i'm not trying to bring any hammer down, it's just something i feel has something worth arguing for.

Quote:

Girl Talk's music especially can't be taken on its own terms, because its cleverness is based on dot-connecting. Sampling, no matter how creative (again, not creative enough in this case IMHO), will never suddenly become creating--
um, that's exactly what i'm trying to say it is, and others try to pass off worse efforts as such, and this is one of the few i feel has acheived that

Quote:

and that's not the point.
i think it's a pretty major part

Quote:

I would argue that the Avalanches' and Shadow's music utilizes the capabilities of computer-based sequencing and sampling much more extensively than Girl Talk. One analogy that comes to mind: the former two would twist the words in a given sentence into new catchphrases, while Girl Talk simply rearranges them and renders them gibberish. This may seem to contradict my above claim that Girl Talk is not indecipherable, but it's more the effect of being able to read the collection of words, which never congeal into a full sentence. Not to take the hackneyed concept too seriously, but there's quite literally no "statement" being made here.
what about that makes them more valuable than what we have here? more computer time=more work=more worth? they're crtainly doing something different, something more catchy with their craft, and the avalanches no doubt trounce this into the next month's lunch, but i fail to see how that aspect you point out renders girl talk not worth the time of day.

den 06-15-2006 10:53 PM

Re: Party album of the CENTURY
 
I haven't had a chance to listen to this yet (though I'm intrigued) so all I have to add is, man, Superdrag 'Sucked Out'. I have not even thought about that song in years.

Tom 06-16-2006 02:22 AM

Re: Party album of the CENTURY
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Animal Boything
Also: Where's Tom? I think he'd like this album too.
PAGING DETOUR TO THIS THREAD


I donwloaded the clip when you first posted it, I didn't hate it, but it seemed a little samey - soulwax, playgroup, earworm etc.

But if you insist that the whole album is hot I will check it out :)

dubman 06-16-2006 08:50 AM

Re: Party album of the CENTURY
 
i was just edited my tom.
i feel all flush.


perhaps the best i've ever had?

bas_I_am 06-16-2006 08:33 PM

Re: Party album of the CENTURY
 
Hey, Thats Vanilla Ice, isnt it???

34958hq439-qjw9v5jq298v5j 06-18-2006 10:11 AM

Re: Party album of the CENTURY
 
I just heard this the other day, I thought it was pretty interesting...most of the music sampled really ain't my style though, and when he sampled "My Humps" I nearly had to turn it off, what a godawful song that is! Interesting mashups though...reminds me a bit of that thing they did with the two Nickelback songs, putting one in each speaker to show how similar they were...this really seems to say something about how all pop music is more or less the same, although I doubt that's the point he was trying to make. Anyone hear any of his other stuff?

Strangelet 06-18-2006 08:20 PM

Re: Party album of the CENTURY
 
i think its best not to get overly analytical with music like this, because that seems to defeat the entire point of "party" The claim was this is the party album of the century, not the album of the century, and if music isn't subjective than what constitutes a good party certainly is.

I don't know my parents beat me and locked me in a closet, but I assume parties are like people hanging out dangling drinks in their hands and every once in a while a rhythm track from KCHEEZ 99 FM, classic oldies comes in, and you get a few friendly nods and maybe someone singing loudly and its done what it needs to do, not like save the planet or something.

kid cue 06-18-2006 09:03 PM

Re: Party album of the CENTURY
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by dubman
i completly do not understand how something can be ironic without it intending to be.

Well ... I guess I'm just saying that it still sounds like ironic music to me, and that has more of an effect on my interpretation of the record than Girl Talk's own statements do. As Tom mentions, it's a lot like the Playgroup mega-DJ Eighties mix, just with less interesting mixes, worse flow, and more hype. :D

Quote:

um, that's exactly what i'm trying to say it is, and others try to pass off worse efforts as such, and this is one of the few i feel has acheived that
I do understand you're saying that Girl Talk is creating something very new, but I felt you, or maybe just Animal Boything, were still conflating what amounts to a simple extension of DJ ideas with a raw exploration of new territory. The source of my distaste for this music is my feeling that he is basically caricaturing all that is good and valuable about DJ/mashup culture simply by exaggerating its core qualities between 2 - 3.5 times over, yet is interpreted as profoundly breaking away from all of that by drawing on some personal genius sensibility. I think that's totally misguided!

Quote:

more computer time=more work=more worth?
Never said anything of the sort. More ideas, more like. :)

kid cue 06-18-2006 09:06 PM

Re: Party album of the CENTURY
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Strangelet
i think its best not to get overly analytical with music like this, because that seems to defeat the entire point of "party" The claim was this is the party album of the century, not the album of the century, and if music isn't subjective than what constitutes a good party certainly is.

While I would normally disagree with you on principle, I do feel that I've over-stretched myself here--others certainly deserve this amount of controversy and more, like M.I.A. or somesuch. :D


All times are GMT -7. The time now is 10:21 AM.

Powered by vBulletin®
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.